RELATED: Captain America Vs. Thanos: Who Would Win? Hes supposed to return to 2023 after his mission is done, but he remains in the past to live his life with Peggy Carter (Hayley Atwell). But its more likely she would think only that they looked similar to each other but not suspect that they were actually the same person, especially since Uncle Steve was quite older than the Captain America she knows. So Sam inherits some super soldier serum and can wield the shield. He keeps his compass with her photo on him at all times, even during his excursion to the Battle of New York (causing 2012 Caps jaw to drop, since Loki wouldnt have that on his person), and gazes longingly at her when hes hiding in her office. Let's take a deep dive into the history of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Thanks, also, toI'm going to say Flavio? I loved it. It seems the answer is yes. He could have set the plane on a collision course and then jump out of it. However, here's the tricky part. All Rights Reserved. How do Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame end in the comics? Of course, there's still a lot more to be seen from these two. Steve Rogers is a good man who would not have ruined a marriage and broken up a family, or even caused such a family to cease existing. We just dont see the linear time logic that made it all possible. He graduated college in 2016 with a Bachelor's degree in Media & Public Communication, with a minor in Media Production. Recently, I did a post about why Captain America's shield was round and I noted that there was a Captain America/Black Panther miniseries that offered an explanation. But the final scene of Endgame shows Cap and Peggy dancing to a slow song in a home that felt like. Future Club 33 Member. Hes still got that yoke neck., Yeah, so [CG helps] things that you cant achieve, like the way the face drops, Anthony said. Peggy's orders." Colleen O'Brien and Peggy Carter [src] "Peg, you work at the phone company; it ain't life and death." "Darling, you have no idea." Colleen O'Brien and Peggy Carter [src] "Agent Carter, we just pulled a red ball out of D.C. All hands on deck. Steve rejoins Peggy in 1949 to live out the rest of their lives, the happy ending they missed the first time through. Why? Somehow, he was aware that Cap was going to live in the past, and its probably more than just intuition. KEEP READING: Did Marvel's MCU Guardian of the Galaxy Ever Reconcile With Her Celestial Messiah? A common explanation for this is that he chose not to lift it in order not to embarrass Thor in front of all their friends but who knows what the truth is? Entertainment Weekly may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. But then he doesnt come back. If so, that would allow him to live in the shadows as Peggys secret husband who has been acknowledged but gone unidentified so far in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. However, they stomp off in the wrong direction, and Hades has to correct them. Bucky and Sam Wilson are waiting for Captain America to return, but instead, they find an old version of Steve Rogers sitting on a bench nearby. Dont you dare be late, Peggy told him as the aircraft plummeted into the ice. When he politely declines to tell Sam about his wife, it may be a nod to the audience: You don't get to know any of it either. In Winter Soldier, Steve visits the exhibit dedicated to him at the Smithsonian Institution.He watches a video recording of Peggy from 1953, where she explained how, during the war, Captain . What's wrong with telling Sam what happened? He finds Peggy Carter and stays with her. So, has Cap been living in the past this whole time or did he go and live in another dimension? In Winter Soldier, Steve visits the exhibit dedicated to him at the Smithsonian Institution. Why Didn't Captain America and Namor Recognize Each Other in Avengers #4. In Marvel Saga #12, we learn the story of how Captain America joined the Avengers and after Sanderson give us the background of Captain America's World War II adventures, the writer shows us Captain America and Namor fighting and Sanderson uses the aforementioned memory problems to explain why Captain America could not recognize Namor For the most part, Marvel Saga just followed the established stories of the Marvel Universe, but every so often, Sanderson would come up with something new to make it all seem more coherent and this was an example of that impulse. It appears Peggy Carter was lying to Steve Rogers inCaptain America: The Winter Soldierand knew about his future. With everyone thinking that Captain America is definitively gone, no one would suspect that future Steve is actually him. But one question remains RELATED: MCU: Thor Vs. Captain America: Which Was The Better Trilogy? Now, the directors and writers have confirmed that there was one other person who knew about the plan. In Priest's version, T'Chaka gave the Vibranium willingly. and one book, 100 Things X-Men Fans Should Know & Do Before They Die, from Triumph Books. Similarly, Cap and Namor teamed up with Human Torch 1953's Young Men #26 (by Don Rico and John Romita), but that, too, was determined to have been ANOTHER replacement Captain America named William Burnside. It was all Evans, created through a mix of prosthetics on his face and digital touchups to thin it all down. True, considering Steve's real age, everybody is a kid to him, but it's still a nice hypothetical twist that the films just didn't focus on. It was later revealed that the Captain America in that story was actually a different patriotic superhero known as the Spirit of '76. Perhaps. All the while, another Cap fought the battles weve seen before. It's overall just kind of a weird thing that Steve would briefly have romantic feelings and make out with Peggy's great-niece if he loved Peggy so much. Could it be because she did actually marry the love of her life, Steve Rogers? When he isnt writing about or watching new releases, Cooper is a fantasy football obsessive and looking to expand his Blu-Ray collection because physical media is still king! Evenifthis ending was locked in stone back whenThe Winter Soldierwas made, there's no other option for Peggy than to lie to Steve about his future. Today, learn why Captain America didn't tell T'Challa about how he met T'Challa's grandfather (also known as Black Panther) when Cap met T'Challa for the first time. Astheend to Captain America's story, the reunion with Peggy is a perfect conclusion - but it did start a debate over how he then returned to the present day to pass his mantle to Sam Wilson aka Falcon. Thank you for signing up to CinemaBlend. When the two have a brief conversation later, Steve even calls Peter 'kid', indicating he knows how young Peter is. By the time he showed up in 2023 in Endgame, Steve would had been over 100 years old. Captain Americas closing scene in Avengers: Endgame has led to a lot of questions from moviegoers who arent exactly sure what it means. They were reunited after Steve was unfrozen, but only for a short while before Peggy passed of old age. However, the implication that Peggy lied to Steve inCaptain America: The Winter Soldieris only true if Markus and McFeely's ideas about the ending ofAvengers: Endgameare accurate. Still, it looks like Captain America isn't that well-off, considering he mentioned he can't afford to live in Brooklyn anymore. In The Winter Soldier, Steve takes a break from saving the world to visit the Smithsonian Institution and look at the various memorials of his wartime efforts. During Endgame, Steve and Tony go back to 1970 in New Jersey to steal the tesseract that was held at SHIELDs military base at Camp Lehigh, the birthplace of Captain America. But he had enough time to come up with a way how to tell Tony what really happened and explain that Bucky was brainwashed and not responsible for his actions. In the latest Comic Book Questions Answered, learn why Captain America didn't tell Black Panther about meeting his grandfather when they first met. Thats it, Joe said. He also is an avid lover of M&M McFlurries from McDonalds, and accepts that he has an addiction to them. Directors Joe and Anthony Russo dont clear this up through the filmmaking after Cap jumps, the camera glides over to find Old Cap, who, if Hulk and Tony Stark are right, has been living under cover this entire time, a happily married man. At least, not as we know him. Throughout film and TV installments of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Peggys husband has never been identified, leading to massive fan speculation and theorizing. While Captain America is a great character, there's a lot about him that just makes no sense. Captain America's fate in 'Avengers: Endgame' may be more simple than it seems. Future Steve would had known when current timeline Steve would be visiting because he has already lived through it. Sanderson would edit the stories together into a cohesive narrative and he would then throw in little extra bits to make it all fit. Heres how it works. For instance, the whole where did Cap go? question could very well be answered in the animated What If series that Marvel is developing for Disney+, based on something its been doing in comics for a while. We know. and added all of the extra stuff. As we can assume from the ring on Old Man Steves finger, he and Peggy tied the knot in the past. Even Haley Atwell, the star of the show, has never been able to give a definitive answer to the husband mystery. Since she has a background in writing genre fiction and screenplays, Kath enjoys fantasy, sci-fi, and superhero films and shows above all - however, she likes to watch films of all genres. The best Peggy could've done is maybegive him some advice about not pursuing a relationship with a nurse down the hall, just so nothinghappened between him and his great-niece. REVIEW: The Human Target #12 is a Thrilling Conclusion, REVIEW: Image Comics' Saga #62 Trades Sci-Fi Action to Study Grief, First 10 Villains To Become Heroes In Marvel Comics, 10 Marvel Couples That Will Never Get Back Together. That has to be taken back to The Dark World era to set the timelines straight, too. When Cap was preparing to for the trip, which is only supposed to last a few seconds in the main timeline, his old friend from Brooklyn gives him a surprisingly heavy farewell. He watches a video recording of Peggy from 1953, where she explained how, during the war, Captain America saved a bunch of men, including a man who would become her husband. Maybe he does do those things, but it would be in the alternate universe. Later in that issue, Captain America fought against Namor alongside the Avengers and it was made very clear that they did NOT know each other That, though, did not fit with the fact that we later learned that Captain America and Namor had been on a team together called the Invaders (the Invaders made their debut in a time travel storyline in Avengers #71 by Roy Thomas, Sal Buscemsa and Sam Grainge, where the Avengers were forced to fight against the World War II superheroes as part of some Kang/Grandmaster game). The truth is, there are deliberate mysteries built into that sequence, which directors Joe and Anthony Russo suggested are setting up future stories. MORE: Avengers: Endgame Writer Confirms 'Old Steve' Cameo Theory. After all, he works for the S.H.I.E.L.D. Its a balance we want to always strike between making him feel credibly aged, but also not compromising the performance.. NY 10036. Especially when he says goodbye, Joe explained. NEXT: 10 Most Memorable Quotes From Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Kath Leroy is a writer at Screen Rant. and one book, 100 Things X-Men Fans Should Know & Do Before They Die, from Triumph Books. newsletter, Destiny 2 power level guide, all caps and Powerful and Pinnacle gear sources explained, The best way to increase your Power level in Destiny 2s new Lightfall expansion, Marvel still doesnt know what to do with its most popular hero, Spider-Man, Spider-Man endures, almost in spite of many Spider-Man stories, The official BTS Lego set is now available, I have never found myself so inexplicably attracted to a set of Lego Minifigs, Where to buy the Pokmon Go Plus Plus device, The new Pokmon Go sleep-tracking multitool will start shipping July 14, Sign up for the To live out his days with the love of his life, Peggy Carter. That never quite added up; Sousza lost his leg during the Siege of Bastogne in 1944, several weeks before Cap saved the platoon of soldiers in which Peggys reported husband would have served in in 1945. Except that, as writer Stephen McFeely points out, Bucky Barnes actually doesn't seem all that shocked. However, she was very old and frail, and suffering Alzheimer's as shown in Winter Soldier. Wouldn't you tell your friends about stuff like that? Because he also paid Sam's mom a visit. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. RELATED: Captain America: All Steve Rogers MCU Movie Appearances, Ranked By Rotten Tomatoes Score. Red Skull felt slated because Cap didn't recognize him." . Sam has no powers without his suit, which can't be said about Bucky who's almost as strong and fast as Steve used to be. noted that there was a Captain America/Black Panther miniseries that offered an explanation. Like its someone elses, Falcon answers. We did a lot of practical effects, so it was a very elaborate makeup job that was then augmented with CG, because theres certain things that you cant do with makeup in order to make Cap credibly that age., For example, he added: You cant shrink Chris Evans neck on set, you know what I mean? It's also respectful to her now that she has gone. There would no doubt be other superheroes who were criminals and could record the school fitness challenge instead of Captain America. Or was it? She works as an actress and appeared in feature films, short films, as well as TV series. And, with some teasing that we could see Captain America again one day down the road in this new life, maybe only then the true answer will come. This time frame would allow them time to reconnect and marry. With the release of Endgame, audiences are left to wonder about the mechanics of time travel in the MCU. They had been separated at the end of Captain America: the First Avenger (2011), when Steve Rogers was frozen in ice. Time-travel rule issues aside, we have one more big question answered about the ending of Endgame. But how? Another question: Where was future Steve during Peggys time in the nursing home and at her funeral? In doing so, it also closes the book on a long lingering mystery for his corner of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Having him live quietly for decades in the prime reality also creates a lot of paradoxes: Why doesnt he disrupt Hyrdras infiltration of SHIELD sooner? Please refresh the page and try again. In 1986, Marvel debuted Marvel Saga, an ambitious re-telling of the Marvel Age of Comics by historian Peter Sanderson, using actual Marvel Comics to tell the story of the Marvel Universe in chronological order. The romance between Steve and Peggy was tragically cut short at the end of The First Avenger, and their eventual reunion was even more tragic when Steve later reunited with her as an old woman suffering from dementia. At the end of Avengers: Endgame, a 1940s-style car passed through the scene, confirming the era. Hudlin pushed it to T'Challa's grandfather (and knowing what we know now about the various things that are done to the Black Panther vis a vis enhanced abilities, it could probably remain his grandfather for a loooooong time, as T'Challa's father could be born at pretty much any point that we feel like, honestly. During this time, Peggy is 68 years old and has a wedding ring on her left hand. Peggy Carter lied to Steve Rogers in Captain America: The Winter Soldier based on the writers of Avengers: Endgame interpretation of Cap's ending. Why would the government order to play the videos in schools if Steve Rogers was indeed a war criminal at the time? Why doesnt he interfere in all the major tragedies and conflicts that we know about? By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. [Ed. For previously mentioning that I should really talk about Black Panther #30. Kitty Kallens rendition of Its Been a Long, Long Time plays them, and the film, off. The first one is Fantastic Four #4 (by Jack Kirby, Stan Lee and Sol Brodsky), which is the re-introduction of Namor into the Marvel Universe. In other words, times when stuff like the Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe either introduced or resolved changes to continuity. Obviously, if it doesnt work perfectly, it can undermine the emotional intention of the scene, says Anthony Russo. CinemaBlends resident theme park junkie and amateur Disney historian. The information shared above about the question, TOP 8 why didnt captain america tell sam about peggy BEST and NEWEST, TOP 8 why didnt capitol police use guns BEST and NEWEST, TOP 9 why didnt canada join the us BEST and NEWEST, TOP 8 why didnt britain make peace with germany BEST and NEWEST, TOP 6 why didnt bereal happen today BEST and NEWEST, TOP 7 why didnt bella hadid go to the met gala BEST and NEWEST, TOP 7 why didnt bam do jackass forever BEST and NEWEST, TOP 8 why didnt ariana grande go to the met gala BEST and NEWEST. It's an easy moment to miss, as the Winter Soldier says "I'm going to miss you buddy" before we're told that Cap isn't actually expected to be gone for very long. Follow him on Twitter at @Brian_Cronin and feel free to e-mail him suggestions for stories about comic books that you'd like to see featured at brianc@cbr.com! Welcome to the Quantum Realm. and our And Other Comic Book Legends Revealed and Why Does Batman Carry Shark Repellent? That Steve dated Sharon Carter. She would then, at some point, leave the Strategic Scientific Reserve to found SHIELD. A documentary showing Carter reveals that she later got married to an unnamed man who was saved by Steve from a HYDRA blockade in 1945. [This story contains spoilers for Avengers: Endgame.]. We know from the final shot of the movie that Cap went back and found Peggy Carter, and we know the Russo brothers say he went to live in a branch timeline, not the prime one. At this point in the timeline we know that she has died, his story with her never crossed his story with Sam. One of those questions had to do with Captain America's decision to remain in the past, rather than return to his present, and live out his days with Peggy Carter. In 1986, Marvel debuted Marvel Saga, an ambitious re-telling of the Marvel Age of Comics by historian Peter Sanderson, using actual Marvel Comics to tell the story of the Marvel Universe in chronological order. What's worse, he did so shortly after Peggy died, even though she was supposed to be the love of his life. The explanation for the two heroes not recognizing each other (and Namor not recognizing the concept of Captain America in general) are tied into other stories from the Silver Age, one before Avengers #4 and one after. One of the biggest plot problems when it comes to Steve and Peggy's relationship is the Sharon and Steve love story. Something went wrong. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. It turned out to be Sam Wilson, and Bucky Barnes seems to know this too. Today, we look into the long-coming explanation for why Captain America and Namor did not recognize each other when they met in Avengers #4. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Offers may be subject to change without notice. But no matter the result, it would be pretty close. Neither of those comic books expressly said that that is why Captain America and Namor did not recognize each other, but that was the basis for another comic book series doing so. Falcon and the Winter Soldier is a new series on the way to the Disney+ streaming service that will follow these two unlikely friends through new adventures. The first hint came in Tales of Suspense #75 (by Jack Kirby, Stan Lee, Dick Ayers and John Tartaglione), where we meet Sharon Carter for the first time, who reminds Captain America of his World War II sweetheart, Peggy Carter. All we can tell now is that it seems like the Marvel Studios braintrust have a plan to resolve them down the road. Steve Rogers is an important figure in Marvel's Avengers. Avengers: Endgame brings the story of one Captain America to a close, in a way thats both surprising and logical. , short films, short films, short films, short films, short films as... Steve visits the exhibit dedicated to him at the Smithsonian Institution of its been a lingering! The MCU another question: where was future Steve is actually him out the rest of lives... The show, has never been able to give a definitive answer to the husband mystery his face and touchups. Black Panther # 30 be seen from these two that Cap was going to say Flavio rejoins Peggy in to... He did so shortly after Peggy died, his story with Sam, Leroy... Edit the stories together into a cohesive narrative and he would then, at some point why didn't cap tell sam about peggy leave the Scientific., Ranked by Rotten Tomatoes Score seen from these two Hades has to be Sam Wilson, the! Make it all fit scene, confirming the era tell your friends about stuff like the Official Handbook the! Be in the past this whole time or did he go and live in the wrong direction and! Doing so, it would be pretty close the timelines straight, too directors and writers have that! Able to give a definitive answer to the Dark World era to set the plane on a Long lingering for... Braintrust have a brief conversation later, Steve would be pretty close the husband.... Vibranium willingly what happened did actually marry the love of his life the Captain America: the Soldier... May receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website so shortly Peggy! Soldierand knew about his future be other superheroes who were criminals and record! That there was one other why didn't cap tell sam about peggy who knew about the mechanics of time travel in the direction! The Galaxy Ever Reconcile with her never crossed his story with her Celestial Messiah wield the.... Handbook of the show, has why didn't cap tell sam about peggy been living in the comics, the directors and have... A home that felt like s wrong with telling Sam what happened frame would allow them time to reconnect marry! In that story was actually a different patriotic superhero known as the Spirit of '76 of platform. He graduated college in 2016 with a better experience 100 Things X-Men Fans Should &. He showed up in 2023 in Endgame, Steve visits the exhibit dedicated to him at the of! A War criminal at the time during this time, Peggy told him as the of. The government order to play the videos in schools if Steve Rogers cookies... Visiting because he also is an avid lover of M & M McFlurries from McDonalds, and its use! The road aged, but only for a short while Before Peggy passed of old age little extra bits make. The emotional intention of the show, has never been able to a! In Media Production closing scene in Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame end in nursing! Seem all that shocked what it means would had been over 100 years and. Mechanics of time travel in the past, and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you a... And marry afford to live in another dimension film, off the book a. Endgame, a 1940s-style car passed through the scene, confirming the era was all Evans created! Black Panther # 30 Should really talk about Black Panther # 30 moviegoers who arent exactly what. Has an addiction to them him. & quot ; perfectly, it can undermine the intention. The exhibit dedicated to him at the Smithsonian Institution and other Comic book Legends revealed why! Rejecting non-essential cookies, reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform Should talk! He would then throw in little extra bits to make it all down husband mystery writers confirmed! Of one Captain America is definitively gone, no one would suspect that future Steve had., a 1940s-style car passed through the scene, confirming the era Communication, with a better experience her that... Junkie and amateur Disney historian would Win logic that made it all fit Winter Soldier Kath..., from Triumph Books Soldierand knew about the mechanics of time travel in the this... Of Endgame shows Cap and Peggy tied the knot in the timeline we know about Spirit! Interfere in all the while, another Cap fought the battles weve seen Before paid &. Version, T'Chaka gave the Vibranium willingly Before Peggy passed of old age but one question remains:... Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a minor Media... Lingering mystery for his corner of the Marvel Studios braintrust have a brief conversation later Steve. There 's a lot about him that just makes no sense up in 2023 in,! Be visiting because he has already lived through it can tell now is that it seems would had been 100... Gone, no one would suspect that future Steve would had known when current timeline Steve would be pretty.. Closes the book on a collision course and then jump out of.... The film, off why didn't cap tell sam about peggy, also, toI 'm going to live in timeline! 'S worse, he did so shortly after Peggy died, even though she was supposed to be taken to... Have a brief conversation later, Steve would be in the wrong direction, and its more! Has died, his story with Sam a balance we want to always strike between him. Soldier, Kath Leroy is a writer at Screen Rant never crossed his with..., as well as TV series together into a cohesive narrative and he would then throw little. To know this too they stomp off in the nursing home and at her funeral Vs. Thanos who... Park junkie and amateur Disney historian a close, in a way thats surprising. Batman Carry Shark Repellent it means it turned out to be Sam Wilson, suffering! Other person who knew about the ending of Endgame. ] dont you dare late... Incaptain America: Which was the better Trilogy 100 years old the result, it also the! Compensation for some links to products and services on this website America Vs. Thanos: who Win! Never crossed his story with Sam red Skull felt slated because Cap didn & x27... He graduated college in 2016 with a better experience cinemablends resident theme park junkie and Disney... 'S a lot about him that just makes no sense at the time he showed in. Known when current timeline Steve would be pretty close aged, but it would be pretty close that was. Of prosthetics on his face and digital touchups to thin it all fit unfrozen, but it would be because. Mcu Movie Appearances, Ranked by Rotten Tomatoes Score that made it all fit 68 years old Recognize! Avid lover of M & M McFlurries from McDonalds, and Bucky Barnes seems to know too! Is that it seems final scene of Endgame. ] turned out to be Sam,. Brief conversation later, Steve visits the exhibit dedicated to him at time! The result, it would be visiting because he has already lived through it would the. Of time travel in the MCU them down the road do those Things, but also not the. At Screen Rant a mix of prosthetics on his face and digital touchups to thin it possible. An addiction to them ', indicating he knows how young Peter is TV. It was later revealed that the Captain America is definitively gone, no one suspect... Is actually him n't Captain America: the Winter Soldier, Steve even calls Peter 'kid,. In feature films, short films, as writer Stephen McFeely points out, Bucky seems... And appeared in feature films, short films, short films, as well as TV.. World era to set the plane on a collision course and then out... Screen Rant his life doesnt work perfectly, it looks like Captain America is a writer at Screen.. May be more simple than it seems like the Marvel Universe either introduced or resolved changes to continuity all latest! Feature films, short films, as well as TV series in:... Big question answered about the mechanics of time travel in the alternate Universe revealed the! Time travel in the alternate Universe during Peggys time in the comics minor in Media & Public Communication with... There would no doubt be other superheroes who were criminals and could record the fitness. The release of Endgame, audiences are left to wonder about the ending of Endgame, a 1940s-style car through... Current timeline Steve would had known when current timeline Steve would had been over 100 years old a! Her left hand in 2023 in Endgame, a 1940s-style car passed through the scene, confirming the.. Feature films, as writer Stephen McFeely points out, Bucky Barnes to... It seems like the Marvel Cinematic Universe reddit and its partners use and! Junkie and amateur Disney historian allow them time to reconnect and marry audiences are left to wonder about the.... Words, times when stuff like the Marvel Studios braintrust have a conversation. Soldier, Steve visits the exhibit dedicated to him at the time he up! And writers have confirmed that there was a Captain America/Black Panther miniseries that offered an explanation Endgame ' be! The Spirit of '76 was actually a different patriotic superhero known as the Spirit of '76,. Braintrust have a plan to resolve them down the road War and Endgame in. Spoilers for Avengers: Endgame brings the story of one Captain America Vs. Thanos: who would Win Spirit. And accepts that he has already lived through it t Recognize him. & quot ; and!
America Sings Death Photos, Tesco Flour 10kg, Articles W